Should the Legal Drinking Age be increased to 21? Tejvan Pettinger society Readers Question:
Follow TIME Every year around this time, millions of American kids graduate from high school, throw massive parties and get drunk. Police end up arresting a lot of these kids, causing them legal trouble for months or even years.
So, every year around this time, there's a new debate about whether we should lower or even abolish the legal drinking age. McCardell has won some favorable news coverageand when I first e-mailed him last year, I told him his idea sounded persuasive.
After all, in almost every other legal and cultural respect, you're an adult at You can vote, adopt children, sign up for Iraq or become a commercial pilot at Treating alcohol differently helps turns it into a holy grail of adulthood.
Always unsupervised, done in secret and too often excessive, this style of drinking has no doubt been responsible for the alarming rise in rates of so-called 'binge' drinking seen at colleges.
First of all, while binge drinking is a serious problem, the data do not show that it has gotten worse since states raised their drinking age. And no researchers have documented an increase in the percentage of alcohol-poisoning deaths among college students, although the raw number has probably increased with the growing college population.
There's a more basic problem: If the drinking age is lowered to 18, who is to provide the supervision that McCardell suggests? Surely not bar owners who want to sell them as many drinks as possible.
It's unclear why shifting the venue of drinking from frat houses to bars will help solve the problem of hard-core student drinking. Finally, lowering the drinking age to 18 would stop infantilizing college students, but it would probably kill more of them in traffic accidents.
In2, people ages 16 to 20 died in alcohol-related fatalities on U.
But that's simply not true. McCardell is right that the U.
But lowering the drinking age is going too far.Voters aged 16 to 17 had a higher turnout rate than older voters under age 30 in Norway’s elections, voters under 35 in Scotland’s referendum election, and voters aged in Austria’s elections in and "Raising the legal minimum age for cigarette purchaser to 21 could gut our key young adult market () " – Philip Morris report, January 21, A March report by the Institute of Medicine (now called the National Academy of Medicine) strongly concluded that raising the tobacco age to 21 will have a substantial positive impact on.
The Uniform Drinking Act, which compelled states to set the legal drinking age at 21 by withholding ten percent of highway funding from states that kept the minimum legal drinking age at 18, is an example of federal government overreach into state affairs.
"Raising the legal minimum age for cigarette purchaser to 21 could gut our key young adult market () " – Philip Morris report, January 21, A March report by the Institute of Medicine (now called the National Academy of Medicine) strongly concluded that raising the tobacco age to 21 will have a substantial positive impact on. Should the minimum legal driving age be raised to 18? 35% Say Yes 65% Say No There are actually teens that are under the age of 16 that need to be driving. So raising the age will just cause many more issues. You see, there are many young adolescents that have no way to get to and from sports practice due to the fact that their parents . Feb 10, · Return the drinking age to 18 -- and then enforce the law. The current system, which forbids alcohol to Americans under 21, is widely flouted, with disastrous consequences.
Should we Raise the Legal Driving Age? If we raise the legal driving age to, say, 17 years old, wouldn’t 17 year olds have the highest accident rate simply due to lack of experience? Instead of simply raising the driving age, we should continue to implement programs which slowly gives more driving privileges to teens as they prove.
Raise the Smoking Age to 21 to advise Congress of the health benefits of raising the age of tobacco sales from 18 years old to legislation that raised the minimum legal sales age. Drinking: 18 vs. 21 Alcohol on campus: debating lowering the drinking age.
U.S. President Ronald Reagan signs legislation on July 17, , raising the national drinking age to 21 as MADD founder Candy Lightner looks on. AP photo There is something to the argument that Age 21 creates disrespect for the law, but I could say the same.